I have given small, but regular donations to Wikipedia over many years, because I believe Wikipedia provides real value and contributes to the sharing of knowledge and information between human beings. Today I got another donation reminder from Jimmy, and I might as well publish my knee jerk response:
Hello,
I support Wikipedia. But this year I have not yet made up my mind with regard to donations.
Companies like OpenAI, Google, Meta and Microsoft are collectively causing the destruction of the free internet with generative AI technology. The open web made by humans for humans is dying, and it is replaced with machine garbage slop. Communication between humans is clouded by gen-AI-transformations, bots, made up fakes of all kinds and deceptive social media algorithms.
And these companies steal whatever data they can get their hands on without any ethical considerations, solely for their own profit. These are highly unethical companies that cause direct harm to [the] human civilization with their technology and actions.
Before I consider donating to Wikipedia going [forward], I want to know that such a donation does not contribute even the slightest to the enrichment of the big tech companies, by enabling them to continue harvesting fresh data from Wikipedia.
What are you doing to:
- Stop AI companies data theft, which is enabling only their own enrichment.
- Stop AI slop from degrading the quality of Wikipedia articles.
- Stop bots from producing fake and potentially ad biased content on Wikipedia.
Thanks,
Øyvind Stegard
I don’t expect to receive a reply. And I know Wikipedia is already taking actions against abuse, but I think it is such an urgent matter that they should put statements about it directly in all their requests for more donations. Also, they are allowing AI companies API-access through payment, but this is not good enough. AI big tech should be outright denied access.
The world is changing. I am no longer sure I want to directly support a huge source of data for unethical AI companies. Maybe all hope is lost for sites like this, and maybe it is better that Wikipedia and the rest of web dies a slow death by AI slop, so that the AI bots can harvest and ingest their own excrement to an increasing extent. Bullshit if you like. It’s the same thing. Words, pixels and sound samples computed by soulless mindless mega clusters of hardware. No understanding, no creativity, no consciousness – merely replicating and mixing up the stolen art, communication, written knowledge, original ideas and inherent patterns produced by human beings throughout time.
My current stance is becoming clear: generative AI technology is contributing a net negative to humanity. We would be better off without it.
And please do not confuse generative AI with machine learning in general. Generative AI is a specific use of machine learning where the goal is to generate data of some kind. To achieve high enough quality, the efforts required to both train and run the machine learning models are enormous. And so the tech is mostly impossible to democratize and it is not controlled by the people. This gives rise to further power concentration (loss of freedom). And with eternal growth requirements and a profit race to the bottom, the data, energy and hardware requirements are rising rapidly. Nobody is holding these damned companies accountable for the effects of their actions. The negatives are completely drowning in hype noise and global FOMO.
Instead of focusing all efforts on reducing the climate crisis, ending wars and helping people who suffer we get fucking chat bots with “funny” names (to somehow excuse that they are shit), a slew of vibe coded trash software, intellectual skill deterioration, addiction to proprietary LLM services, communication sloppification, hardware price increases, electricity price increases, open web destruction, freedom loss, job loss and fake media all over the place. And in that process we are also making the climate crisis even worse. No fucking LLM is going to solve that.
So I’m sorry Jimmy, but unless you completely deny access to the destructive forces of evil and unethical AI companies, Wikipedia will no longer receive donations from me.
R.I.P. Wikipedia and the world wide web that was.